top of page

Wearing My Gender (Or Am I?)

3 days ago
12 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

Gender expression: What It Means, Why It Matters


I was walking through Manchester city centre yesterday feeling sexy as fuck! It was one of those rare sunny days in winter. I was wearing my white and grey winter coat, a light cream jumper, my mustard-coloured baby alpaca wool scarf (which I spent ages searching for in Peru to find just the right shade), my new brown Chelsea boots and slim-fit trousers I'd bought in Lahore a couple of years ago. I'd trimmed my beard, done my hair and accessorised with sunglasses, a black watch with a gold face and a gold ring.

I looked GOOD!


Now, I appreciate this sounds a little vain, perhaps even narcissistic, but there's something incredibly empowering about wearing boots (cue These Boots Are Made for Walkin' playing in my head), a good coat, particularly one where you can 'pop' the collar up.

And when I say I felt sexy, I don't necessarily mean sexually desirable. Although, admittedly, there's an element of that. Certainly, when I was younger, how attractive others found me mattered considerably more. These days, feeling sexy is more about feeling comfortable and confident in myself, regardless of what anyone else thinks.

Or at least that's the goal.


Fighting Fear Queer health blogs, Gender Expression and Gender Identity. LGBTQ Therapy, Queer therapy, Gay therapist, queer therapy manchester, LGBTQ therapy manchester, queer therapy London, LGBTQ therapy London, queer affirming therapy London, queer affirming therapy manchester, LGBTQ affirming therapy London, LGBTQ affirming therapy manchester. Queer psychotherapy, LGBTQ psychotherapy, queer coach, LGBTQ coach, queer bipoc therapist, Queer therapist manchester, queer therapist London, queer mental health, LGBTQ mental health.

When your outfit is apparently too gay

As I walked through Manchester, I noticed a few stares. Mostly from men. Mostly white men. Dressed in black hoodies, puffer jackets and sportswear. Think Berlin streetwear, but Manchester, so probably something from JD Sports or the big Nike store in the Arndale.

No disrespect to Manchester's fashion scene, but there's a particular sportswear culture here, and a South Asian man walking around in light colours, fitted trousers and a mustard scarf can apparently stand out. And not necessarily in a good way.

More in a "he looks a bit gay" sort of way.


Now, nobody actually said that to me. But I grew up here. I recognise those looks. And trust me, I've spent enough time in gay bars and clubs to distinguish between someone checking me out and someone looking at me with hostility.

And this was a relatively sober outfit!


The irony is that I have considerable privilege in how I navigate these spaces. I'm a cisgender, bisexual Queer man who's had relationships with women and men. I'm relatively straight-passing, able-bodied and athletic. I can move through heterosexual spaces without my sexuality necessarily being questioned, while generally feeling comfortable in Queer spaces too.


That doesn't mean I've never experienced homophobia or racism. It means I recognise that the risks I face when expressing myself are often considerably less than those faced by others.

And that's important to acknowledge.


How can a colour be gay?

In my work as a psychotherapist, I support many Queer people navigating sexuality, gender identity and gender expression.


Sexual attraction can sometimes be easier to understand, at least conceptually. We're attracted to whom we're attracted to. Try as we might, we can't simply force attraction.

Gender, however, introduces another layer of complexity.

There's gender identity, our internal sense of who we are in relation to gender. Then there's gender expression, how we communicate or present that identity through clothing, appearance, behaviour and mannerisms. And finally, there's self-expression, which encompasses much more than gender: our personality, culture, creativity, preferences and individuality.


These can overlap, but they aren't necessarily the same thing.

Take my outfit. Nothing about it was particularly unconventional for a man. Yet the colours, the fit, the accessories apparently made it different, therefore less masculine, and therefore worthy of stares.

How can a colour be gay?

It's not like I was wearing pink!

And I have A LOT of pink. When people tell me I love pink, I usually respond, "Pink loves me." Thank you, Cam from Modern Family.

Of course, there's nothing inherently feminine about pink either. These associations are socially constructed and culturally influenced. There have even been periods in Western fashion history when pink was associated with boys and blue with girls. So yeah, these things change.

Yet we police people relentlessly.

What we wear. How we walk. How we speak. How we gesture. How we sit. Heck, even how we stand!


Not too masculine. Not too feminine. Not too much of anything.

And of course, the rules are different for boys and men than they are for girls and women.

But here's what I find particularly interesting. Sometimes we're not actually trying to express our gender at all. Other people are interpreting our self-expression through their expectations of gender.


A feminine man isn't necessarily gay. A masculine woman isn't necessarily lesbian. An androgynous-looking person isn't necessarily non-binary or asexual.

Aren't these just stereotypes?

I mean, we all hoped Sporty Spice was a lesbian, but she isn't. And imagine what it must have been like having your sexuality speculated about simply because you wore tracksuits, trainers and had an athletic physique.


We assign identities to people based on how they look, then expect them to explain themselves when they don't fit our assumptions.

And just when we think we've overcome other people's judgement, we discover we've internalised it ourselves.


Becoming your own Gender Police

I still occasionally catch myself uncrossing my legs because I'm worried I'm sitting too femininely. Then I realise what I've done, feel ridiculous, and cross them again.

Suddenly I'm sitting there thinking about how I'm sitting, wondering why the hell I'm spending so much energy thinking about sitting when I could be doing literally anything else.

Side note: did you know there's a stereotype that bisexual people can't sit properly in chairs?

That and finger guns, apparently.

Who knew?


But it does make me wonder whether some of our discomfort comes from trying to perform gender correctly. Perhaps I've spent years shifting around in chairs because the way I naturally want to sit doesn't quite fit the masculine expectations I've absorbed.

OR perhaps bisexuals really are just terrible at chairs.

The thing about gender policing is that it's exhausting. And we don't always realise we're doing it.


Sometimes it's unconscious, like uncrossing my legs. Other times it's very deliberate, depending on the environment.

Let's say I'm travelling through the American Bible Belt. I'm probably going to be more conscious about how I present myself. Firstly, because I'm brown, and secondly, because certain aspects of my clothing or mannerisms might attract unwanted attention. Put the two together, particularly in Trump's America, and I'm potentially navigating racism and homophobia simultaneously.

So perhaps I'll tone things down a little.


Now, put me in a gay fetish party and suddenly I'm doing the complete opposite.

Oh, I'm DEFINITELY masc-ing it up there.

Harness? Check.

Fresh pump from the gym? Check.

Beard trimmed? Obviously.

Suddenly I'm performing hypermasculinity because, let's be frank, there's an element of external validation involved.

Do I look fuckable?


In certain gay male spaces, hypermasculinity is associated with desirability. Muscles, facial hair, body hair, dominance, the whole package. And so surprise, being brown can sometimes work in my favour here, although not necessarily for the right reasons. The racial fetishisation of Black and brown men is very much a thing, where our bodies become desirable through stereotypes about masculinity, sexuality and exoticism.

So in one environment, being brown might make me feel more vulnerable. In another, it might make me more sexually desirable.


Same person. Different environment. Different performance.

But what's the psychological cost of constantly adjusting ourselves?

Anxiety, because we're worried someone might notice something we're trying to conceal.

Stress, because we feel we have to maintain a particular image.

Shame, because perhaps we're not masculine or feminine enough.

Low mood, because we begin to believe we'll never quite meet the expectations placed upon us.


Over time, this constant self-monitoring can become exhausting. We're not simply navigating the world; we're continually evaluating how the world might respond to us.

And for some people, this isn't about avoiding discomfort. It's about avoiding danger.


Now let's throw intersectionality into the mix, for shits and giggles

I'm South Asian. Pakistani Punjabi, specifically. And our cultural understanding of masculinity and gender expression isn't identical to Western expectations, to say the least. Punjabis love to stand out. Men and women alike. It's a very loud and visually colourful culture.


Men routinely wear shalwar kameez in whites, creams, blues and other light, sometimes even bright colours. Jewellery, including elaborate rings with precious stones, is hardly unusual.


I have a beautiful silver ring my father had made for me. It's engraved with flowers and holds a sapphire I bought in Skardu, Pakistan, during a trip to the northern regions. I absolutely love it. And I specifically wanted it to stand out.


Yet in certain Western masculine contexts, it's considered excessive. Too decorative. Too feminine. Too much. Apparently, men can wear jewellery, provided it doesn't look like they've made too much effort with it.

A plain wedding band? Fine.

Maybe a watch.

Or a tie pin if you're feeling posh.

An elaborate sapphire ring with floral engravings?

Steady on, mate.


Of course, I'm not suggesting South Asian cultures are somehow free from restrictive gender expectations. Far from it. Gender nonconformity, femininity in men and anything perceived as challenging traditional masculinity can be heavily policed within Pakistani and other South Asian communities too. It's just that the rules aren't always the same.

An elaborate ring might be perfectly acceptable, while a man wearing nail polish could attract considerable judgement.


Which makes you wonder, who actually decided any of this? But here's where things become even more complicated. If I wear traditional Pakistani clothing in Manchester, am I expressing my cultural identity, my gender identity, or simply my personal style?


And what happens when racism enters the equation? Can I wear shalwar kameez without being perceived as threatening, foreign or some sort of Islamist extremist? Or are my traditional clothes only acceptable when someone else wears a vaguely South Asian-inspired costume? Enter Zain and Pradip dressed up as Aladdin and Sinbad at Halloween.

Suddenly, self-expression becomes a negotiation between masculinity, sexuality, race, culture and safety. And that's before we've even considered gender diversity.


The privilege of being able to blend in

An older trans woman lives in my building in Manchester. We occasionally exchange a hello or good morning in the lift. I sometimes have this instinct to offer to help her with her groceries.

I haven't yet.


One morning, on my way to the gym, I saw her slowly crossing the road. Two men in a van at the crossing began revving their engine as she crossed. I can't know with certainty what their intentions were. But the interaction felt threatening, and I couldn't help wondering whether her visible gender expression had something to do with it. I wondered how frightening that might have been. Or perhaps worse, whether she'd experienced enough hostility that this was simply another ordinary morning.


This happened metres from Manchester's Gay Village, literally around the corner from G.A.Y bar. I mean, where are Queer people meant to feel safe?


Think also about a non-binary person who enjoys wearing dresses and nail polish but feels unable to do so around colleagues because of the eye rolls, stares, questions and comments. Why should they have to explain their clothing choices simply because they don't conform to gender expectations? Nobody asks me to justify my Chelsea boots. Or consider a transmasculine person exploring their personal style, perhaps working with a stylist to discover which colours, clothing and silhouettes help them feel comfortable in their gender.

For them, the experience might not simply be about fashion. It might be about finally seeing themselves reflected in the mirror.


These examples remind me that gender expression isn't just about clothing. It's about dignity, belonging, autonomy and, sometimes, safety.


And while my own experiences of being stared at matter, I don't want to pretend they're equivalent to the risks faced by visibly trans, non-binary or gender-nonconforming people.

They aren't. But they do give me a small window into some of the psychological processes involved.


Whilst I can now confidently navigate Manchester city centre wearing what I like, there was a time I felt threatened by the looks, stares and whispers. It happened at school when I bought a denim jacket. It happened at college when I first wore shalwar kameez on a Friday, thinking I could wear it to the mosque afterwards. And it happened in London when I wore a kurta to a nearby café where I lived in Chiswick.


To simply say I became more confident isn't quite enough. I also began accepting the possibility of discomfort and taking calculated risks for the sake of my wellbeing.

But that's an important distinction.


Discomfort and danger are not the same thing. If the likely consequence is feeling embarrassed, receiving a stare or perhaps an occasional comment, there may be opportunities to experiment with expressing ourselves differently.


If the consequence might be violence, losing your job, being rejected by your family or becoming homeless, that's an entirely different calculation. For some people, concealing aspects of their gender expression isn't about lacking confidence. It's about survival.

And I think we need to be careful when encouraging people to simply be themselves, as though everyone has the same freedom to do so.


And so I wonder whether there might be spaces where people can safely experience being themselves without constantly monitoring their behaviour. Perhaps it's with one trusted friend or relative. An online community. A Queer community centre. A club. A supportive group of people. Somewhere they don't have to filter every gesture, every word, every movement.

Because imagine the emotional and cognitive energy involved in being your own gender police all day, every day, for the rest of your life. Surely everyone deserves at least some space where they can put down that responsibility.


When does gender expression become self-expression?

This is the question I've been thinking about. We've explored gender identity and gender expression, but at what point does it all simply become self-expression?

And can it?


Let's imagine, just for a moment, that we remove the threat of discrimination, rejection and violence. That everyone has the freedom to safely experiment with how they present themselves. Would we still feel the need to perform gender?


Or would we simply wear what we liked, move how we wanted and express ourselves without worrying about whether it was masculine, feminine or something else entirely?

For me, something shifted when I stopped caring quite so much about what other people thought and began accepting the occasional comments.

Sometimes I even started owning them.

"Pink loves me."

Most recently, I took this to the nth degree and had a pink linen suit made for my cousin's wedding.

And I have to say, I loooooooooovved it!

I would NEVER have dreamt of wearing something like that when I was younger.


Fighting Fear Queer health blogs, Gender Expression and Gender Identity. LGBTQ Therapy, Queer therapy, Gay therapist, queer therapy manchester, LGBTQ therapy manchester, queer therapy London, LGBTQ therapy London, queer affirming therapy London, queer affirming therapy manchester, LGBTQ affirming therapy London, LGBTQ affirming therapy manchester. Queer psychotherapy, LGBTQ psychotherapy, queer coach, LGBTQ coach, queer bipoc therapist, Queer therapist manchester, queer therapist London, queer mental health, LGBTQ mental health.

What's interesting is that in certain West African fashion traditions, men wear incredibly bold, colourful and elaborate outfits and look damn bloody good doing it. Within those cultural contexts, bright colours aren't necessarily interpreted as feminine or gay.


Again, the same clothing can communicate something entirely different depending on the cultural lens through which it's viewed. And it's not just about colour. I think pink actually suits me. Red, on the other hand? Not so sure I can pull that off. But by playing, and I do consider it playing, with colours, materials, shapes and silhouettes, I've become increasingly comfortable and confident in how I express myself. Not entirely, obviously. I'm still human. I still occasionally uncross my legs. But I began taking calculated risks.


Wearing something brighter. Choosing different silhouettes. Putting on that elaborate ring, not just for special occasions or as some sort of cultural cosplay, but because I wanted to wear it.


Dressing in ways that made me happy rather than ways that made me less noticeable (or more desirable). And here's where I think the distinction between gender expression and self-expression becomes particularly interesting.


When I wear my pink suit, am I expressing femininity? Challenging masculinity? Making a statement about my bisexuality? Or do I simply think I look fucking fabulous in pink? Perhaps the answer depends as much on who's looking as it does on what I'm trying to communicate.

And perhaps that's the problem.


We often assume that how someone presents themselves must tell us something about their gender identity or sexuality. I guarentee someone at that wedding thought he's Gay that's why he's wearing pink (never bi by the way, its always gay, that's another blog) But sometimes it doesn't. Sometimes it's just personal preference.


Of course, this distinction isn't necessarily the same for everyone. For many cisgender Queer people, myself included, there may be greater opportunities to experiment with gender expression without our gender identity itself being questioned or invalidated.


I'm comfortable identifying as a man. Wearing pink doesn't make me feel less masculine, nor does it necessarily mean I'm deliberately expressing femininity. I'm just wearing pink.


For many trans and non-binary people, however, gender expression can carry a different significance.


It may be deeply connected to having their gender recognised and affirmed. A trans woman wearing a dress might be expressing her femininity in a way that feels important to her identity. A transmasculine person might choose particular clothing because it helps them feel more aligned with their sense of self. A non-binary person might embrace androgyny, masculinity, femininity or none of these.


And none of these expressions makes someone's gender identity more or less valid.


Being recognised in your gender, addressed correctly and able to use facilities that align with your identity without fear of harassment can be profoundly important.

So perhaps freedom doesn't necessarily mean gender stops mattering.


It means having greater freedom to decide how much it matters to you. For some people, gender expression is an intentional and affirming part of their identity. For others, it's simply another aspect of their personal style. And for many of us, it's probably a bit of both.


Perhaps the goal isn't to eliminate gender expression, but to stop making it an obligation.

To allow masculinity without policing femininity.

To allow femininity without questioning someone's gender.


To recognise that cultural expression, gender expression and personal style can overlap without necessarily defining one another. And to acknowledge that sometimes the biggest obstacle to self-expression isn't our gender identity at all.


It's other people's expectations of what that identity should look like. Because sometimes a scarf is just a scarf.

A ring is just a ring.

And a man wearing pink isn't necessarily making a statement about his sexuality.

Although, in my case, pink does love me.

As for my Chelsea boots?

They make me feel sexy as fuck.

And perhaps that's enough.


Comments


bottom of page